Build-A-Rig Round 1, Zotac vs. Corsair: The $1500 PC Showdownby Ryan Smith on August 5, 2015 6:00 AM EST
- Posted in
Diving into our showdown, we’ll start with general system performance. While the overall challenge was for a $1500 gaming PC, good gaming performance good overall system performance frequently go hand-in-hand. With gaming stressing virtually every aspect of a system – and not just the GPU – a balanced gaming system should do well on overall system performance as well.
Starting with PCMark 8, PCMark provides various usage scenarios (home, creative and work) and offers ways to benchmark both baseline (CPU-only) as well as OpenCL accelerated (CPU + GPU) performance. We benchmarked select PCs for the OpenCL accelerated performance in all three usage scenarios. These scores are heavily influenced by the CPU in the system.
The different PCMark subtests stress test systems in slightly different ways, but overall there’s a clear pattern here, with the Corsair system always holding an advantage here, upwards of 10%. PCMark 8 in particular does stress the GPU a bit thanks to OpenCL acceleration, but it’s not significant, particularly when you’re comparing systems with high-end GPUs. So the bulk of the difference is due to the difference in processors – a Core i5-4460 (3.2GHz) in the Zotac system, and a Core i5-4690K (3.5GHz) in the Corsair system. Even then, for the older PCMark 7 the two systems are neck-and-neck.
Moving on, we have CINEBENCH R15, an image rendering benchmark. CINEBENCH provides three benchmark modes - OpenGL, single threaded and multi-threaded. Evaluation of select PCs in all three modes provided us the following results.
In the CPU tests the Corsair system has a 15-20% lead, in-line with the differences we’d expect from the choice in processors. Otherwise the OpenGL test is even greater, thanks to the wider difference in GPU performance.
For a look at video encoding performance we have results courtesy of x264 HD Benchmark v5.0. This is simply a test of CPU performance with good scaling with both core count and individual core performance.
Much like under CINEBENCH, Corsair’s system is around 20% faster here, and this goes for both passes. Since the CPUs are Haswell i5s, what we’re seeing here is mostly clockspeed differences.
Up next, 7-Zip is a very effective and efficient compression program, often beating out OpenCL accelerated commercial programs in benchmarks even while using just the CPU power. 7-Zip has a benchmarking program that provides tons of details regarding the underlying CPU's efficiency. In this subsection, we are interested in the compression and decompression MIPS ratings when utilizing all the available threads.
Under 7-Zip the Corsair system yet again holds a roughly 20% performance advantage. Traditionally this benchmark has also shown some sensitivity to memory speeds and timings, but since both systems use Corsair DDR3-1866 kits, this ends up being a pure clockspeed test.
Meanwhile, as businesses (and even home consumers) become more security conscious, the importance of encryption can't be overstated. TrueCrypt is a popular open-source disk encryption program can take advantage of the AES-NI capabilities of modern processors, and even though TrueCrypt is no longer under development, its internal benchmark provides some interesting cryptography-related numbers to ponder.
Like 7-Zip, there’s a fair bit of memory interactions here, but with our systems using identical speed memory, this is another pure clockspeed test. This leads to the Corsair system holding a 22% lead here.
Agisoft PhotoScan is a commercial program that converts 2D images into 3D point maps, meshes and textures. The program designers sent us a command line version in order to evaluate the efficiency of various systems that go under our review scanner. The command line version has two benchmark modes, one using the CPU and the other using both the CPU and GPU (via OpenCL). The benchmark takes around 50 photographs and does four stages of computation:
- Stage 1: Align Photographs
- Stage 2: Build Point Cloud (capable of OpenCL acceleration)
- Stage 3: Build Mesh
- Stage 4: Build Textures
We record the time taken for each stage. Since various elements of the software are single threaded, others multithreaded, and some use GPUs, it is interesting to record the effects of CPU generations, speeds, number of cores, DRAM parameters and the GPU using this software.
Even with GPU participation, there aren’t any surprises here. The Corsair system retains its typical lead, and both GPUs are powerful enough to shift the bottleneck back on the CPU even with the use of OpenCL.
Finally, wrapping up our system benchmark numbers is the Dolphin Emulator benchmark mode results. This is again a test of the CPU capabilities, and how well a CPU can handle emulating the Nintendo Wii’s PowerPC 750 CPU.
This final test is once again to the Corsair system’s advantage, this time by 18%.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
heffeque - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkI'd stay with Zotac's build, even though it doesn't perform as well as Corsair's build.
a1exh - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkBut it has a Z79 motherboard ;)
Ryan Smith - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkWhat'chu talkin' 'bout, Willis? ;)
AndrewJacksonZA - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkHe's talking about "Die Harder." ;-)
a1exh - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkThey had a typo but it's sneakily been fixed.
AndrewJacksonZA - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkCongratulations Dustin, you chalked up a win in my book. :-)
nedge2k - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkI'd like to see a HTPC gaming rig build-off. Only stipulations being the case must be able to take the place of a DVD player (i.e. no towers or shuttles) and it must have a least a dual TV tuner. Oh and a VFD/OLED display would be a bonus.
HOOfan 1 - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkChinny went a little overboard on the CPU cooler and Power Supply, and then spent money on bling instead of more RAM and a better graphics card.
BrokenCrayons - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkI think it's a really classy sort of bling that doesn't go over the top at all.
Gigaplex - Wednesday, August 5, 2015 - linkLED strips are over the top.